Friendly reminder: Click the '↑' above to follow 'FMCG Dealer Professional Consulting' for more marketing and dealer internal management content.
Case: Recently, a dealer shared a dilemma: one of his key salespeople, earning an average monthly base salary of over 3,000 yuan, was still dissatisfied. He secretly altered promotional policies, withheld promotional items, made unauthorized promises to customers behind the boss's back, and unilaterally raised selling prices for personal gain. When exposed, the salesperson left, causing the dealer financial losses and reputational damage. What hurt most was losing a capable assistant he had painstakingly cultivated. He couldn't understand: he treated his employees well, even paying high salaries, yet they remained disloyal. How could he avoid such a 'losing both the battle and the war' situation?
Analysis: Similar situations are common in real life. The reasons are as follows:
Employee psychological imbalance. Dealers differ from enterprises in hiring; enterprises attract talent through platforms and culture, while dealers, with less strength and scale, often need to pay more to recruit and retain. With the same salary standards, salespeople in corporate settings find balance more easily, but in dealer businesses, they see the boss as an individual making money daily, while they, despite decent pay, feel undercompensated compared to the boss, who may have less education and use rough language. This imbalance can lead salespeople to exploit loopholes for psychological compensation, especially those with grudges. Dealers should ask themselves: Are they continuously learning and showcasing their charm and vision? Are they too close to salespeople, revealing their own weaknesses, exacerbating imbalance?
Management loopholes during transition. Some dealers transition too quickly from being 'boss, driver, porter, salesperson' to leaders and managers, leading to numerous gaps. Rules may exist but are incomplete or impractical due to lack of employee input, or they may be 'borrowed' without adaptation. Fear of formalization and strict management may cause employee turnover, making management systems mere decorations, creating a 'management vacuum,' especially for trusted individuals. In the case, the dealer's rapid growth outpaced management, leaving loopholes for the salesperson to exploit. Dealers should reflect: Are systems evolving with the business? Are there outdated or impractical systems? Do salespeople understand and execute them? Are loopholes promptly patched?
Excessive trust becomes indulgence. Some dealers, despite transitioning, haven't implemented true corporate management. Decisions remain one-man shows, management is based on personal relationships rather than humanized systems, and they treat subordinates like brothers, trusting them excessively and relying on their assurances. This lack of effective control leads to problems like in the case, where losses occur before realization. Therefore, dealers should consider: Are high-performing salespeople loyal? Does the company have mechanisms to ensure loyalty? Is there a talent development system? Are there backups if people leave? What kind of relationship should they have with core salespeople: brothers, employees, subordinates, or business partners?
Additionally, incomplete processes, salespeople operating outside rules, lack of dynamic management and control over downstream channels, and poor information flow contribute to loss of control over markets and personnel.
Countermeasures: To plug the 'high salary without loyalty' loophole, establish a prevention system. Suggestions:
Transition gradually, focusing on both big and small. Dealers often go to extremes: either too loose or seeking 'one-step' perfection. Instead, follow a gradual approach, clarifying responsibilities as the company grows, implementing systematic management step by step, delegating appropriately, and allowing employees time to adapt. Tighten controls gradually to avoid overwhelming them. Also, don't over-delegate; stay involved by visiting the market regularly, understanding salespeople, and maintaining communication with downstream channels to avoid being misled.
Management systems must be implemented and executed. Some dealers recognize the importance of systems and even establish comprehensive structures, but often they become formalities, like decorative vases. Despite many rules, few are enforced, leading to recurring problems. The issue is lack of execution, especially by the boss. Therefore, systems should be practical, and agreed-upon rules must be enforced thoroughly. For example, strictly punish behaviors like diverting funds, withholding promotional items, or cross-region selling. Publicize cases, set positive and negative examples, and punish violators severely to deter others, preventing problems before they occur.
Establish monitoring mechanisms and process management. To avoid such cases, dealers should set up monitoring systems, including inspection and tracking systems when delegating authority. For instance, create policies for promotional items and rebates, use forms and tools, assign staff (e.g., market or customer service departments) to verify with downstream customers' signatures, and conduct phone or field checks afterward. Manage processes and evaluate effectiveness. Also, inform downstream customers in writing that only policies signed by the dealer and relevant departments are valid, closing all loopholes.
Implement systematic, sustained, and comprehensive training. Dealers may lack advantages in hiring compared to manufacturers, but they can offer training as added value beyond salary. This provides learning opportunities, compensates for weaker company strength and culture, and enhances salespeople's understanding and loyalty. Training should cover mindset (confidence, positivity, optimism, dedication, gratitude), sales skills (customer development, promotion design, pricing, channel management), and professional knowledge (marketing 4P/4C theories, marketing concepts, trends), making the company more attractive and preventing impulsive actions.
Establish regional rotation. To prevent internal 'corruption,' dealers can implement regional rotation, periodically transferring salespeople to different areas to maintain integrity. Also, establish a 'responsibility traceability system,' where even after transfer, the original responsible person remains accountable for their past market and actions. This encourages long-term thinking and mutual supervision, surfacing issues early and serving as a preventive measure.
Innovate compensation mechanisms. To fundamentally change such behavior, improve performance assessment. The salary system is a guide; many problems stem from compensation. For example, commission-based pay may lead to blind stocking regardless of channel health. Instead, adopt a performance-based salary: lower base pay tied to attendance, report submission, attitude, and learning; higher performance pay tied to product mix, sales results, channel visits, customer assistance, consultative selling, customer satisfaction, and personal conduct (e.g., unauthorized promises, fund diversion, borrowing from customers). Additionally, to attract and retain top performers, consider allocating a portion of annual profits as bonuses or shares, paid over time. Also, strictly screen new hires and promptly remove unethical salespeople through performance reviews to avoid 'one bad apple spoiling the barrel' and affecting the whole team.