Tip: Click the blue text above to follow "FMCG Distributor Professional Consulting" for more insights on marketing and distributor internal management.

Method 1: First the Carrot, Then the Stick

Case Study:

Yang Qi, a regional manager with modest education and short tenure, knew over 80% of the more than 100 distributors in his area. Unlike other regional managers, his relationships with distributors were not the typical arms-length, business-only affairs, but closer, tighter, and more personal.

Despite limited resources, unremarkable market position, and little attention from senior leadership, how did he achieve this in his region?

His experience: The carrot and stick must be used skillfully, and "no discord, no concord"—strong bonds are often forged through conflict.

Once, he visited a distributor who was quite well-known in the company. After a routine visit, as we were leaving the city, the big boss called, saying the distributor we had just visited was in a standoff with the delivery staff, and we needed to return immediately. We quickly went back.

The delivery truck was parked at the entrance. We learned that the distributor was short of empty barrels—20 short—and also had an outstanding payment (a small amount) from last time, so the delivery staff refused to unload.

The distributor's reasoning: Given his sales volume with the company, such a trivial matter should be flexible. "You're being unreasonable and disrespectful!"

Clearly, the standoff was about face. Yang Qi walked up to General Manager Zhao, offered a cigarette, smiled, and nodded understandingly at the complaints.

Then, Yang Qi also offered cigarettes to the driver and delivery staff squatting in the truck, saying half-seriously, half-jokingly: "Come on, Boss Zhao is such a big boss; do you think he can't afford these dozens of barrels? It's not your problem. I'll give him these barrels as a gift. When I get back to the company, I'll pay the finance department. And I'll guarantee the outstanding payment with my salary; I'll explain to finance. You go ahead and unload for Boss Zhao."

The delivery staff, taking the hint, unloaded and left.

But the issue wasn't over. After the company's delivery staff left, while having tea with the distributor, Yang Qi turned serious and said with a hint of helplessness: "Boss Zhao, you're a big boss, and you look down on us, especially on me, Xiao Yang!"

The distributor was taken aback, then offered tea with a smile: "How could that be, Manager Yang? What do you mean?"

"Look, we were just chatting here, and you said you consider me a brother and would support our work. But within five minutes, our boss called to reprimand us, saying you didn't call us but went directly to him, which means we're not doing our job well, and that our cooperation has problems!" Yang Qi said.

"Brother, don't say that. I just feel more familiar with your director, so I habitually called him," the distributor interrupted, explaining and promising: "It was my oversight, causing you trouble. It won't happen again. If anything comes up, I'll definitely ask for your help first."

As the atmosphere eased, Yang Qi added: "Boss Zhao, about those 20-plus barrels today, I said I'd give them to you as a personal compensation for our previous shortcomings. Please accept them, and we look forward to your support in the future."

[Commentary] A hungry donkey that gets a carrot won't fear the stick

Difficulties in collecting payments, harsh words, pickiness—common deteriorations in manufacturer-distributor relations are often just minor frictions and conflicts. If mishandled, these small frictions can escalate into major confrontations.

These minor frictions, like quarrels between spouses, are often unrelated to wealth, education, or age, and are usually rooted in trivial, long-standing grievances that can become lingering grudges and gradually grow into major conflicts.

For example, in the case above, the real grudge for Boss Zhao was a comment made by a company delivery person to his staff: "If you're this slow with a few hundred yuan, how can you do big business?" Zhao happened to overhear it, and the grudge festered, erupting repeatedly.

In manufacturer-distributor or distributor-distributor frictions, stubbornly blaming the other side often aims to extract compensation or just win an argument. But these distributors, who often use small tricks, appear righteous and assertive, yet inwardly feel guilty and are eager for a way out.

As a regional manager, the key skill is to mediate (calm both sides), offer a "way out," and also wield the "big stick."

Before delivering the "big stick" (the reprimand to Zhao), the "carrot" (free goods, credit support) was placed right at the "hungry donkey's" mouth, so even if you hit it, the donkey won't get angry or can't afford to.

After this incident, the company's delivery staff, seeing Yang Qi's commitment to the customer, stopped endlessly haggling over similar issues in the future, and even praised his business acumen. The distributor regained face, and word spread that he was a responsible and decisive manager. From then on, their business cooperation went smoothly. When this reached the senior leadership, they also saw him as capable of handling things independently.

A smart manager often demonstrates unique charisma and wisdom in handling such minor conflicts, even turning a work problem into a great public relations opportunity, worth more than countless routine visits and humble inquiries.

Method 2: First the Stick, Then the Carrot

Case Study:

Boss Qiu, a motorcycle parts distributor in Hefei, ranked among the top in sales for Company L and had cooperated for years.

But he had a habit: almost every month, he would rush orders in the last few days, placing several times the usual order, but each time he either paid insufficiently or paid after the goods arrived—often at the beginning of the next month, just before the company calculated rebates. He would repeatedly instruct the regional supervisor to ensure his rebates were calculated, claiming he had exceeded targets and paid.

When I took over the sales department at Company L, my colleagues mentioned this difficulty, and I had discussed it with the general manager. He was also annoyed by Qiu's calls, and the finance department was complaining.

Previous managers had tried refusing shipments or using rebates as leverage, but Qiu, a sly fox, always found new tricks and succeeded.

I communicated with him multiple times by phone and visited him in person, but Qiu wanted both fame and fortune and was impervious to persuasion.

I had to find a way to break this deadlock.

Starting the next month, I took the first step of "delivering the stick": I sent a written notice to all distributors announcing an additional annual distributor rebate on top of the existing monthly sales rebate. The notice clearly stated: All rebates must be based on the actual cash amount received by the finance department that month; special cases require special application to the sales director, no later than the 3rd of the following month; and those with more than two special applications in a year would forfeit the annual rebate.

A few days later, Qiu called. He didn't mention the monthly late payments or rebates at all, only said nice things, expressed support for the annual rebate policy, and ended with: "Director Wang, the parts industry is tough now, with heavy inventory pressure and tight funds. Please take care of me, old Qiu!"

At the end of that month, Qiu repeated his old trick. When the regional supervisor pressed for payment, Qiu used me as a shield, saying Director Wang often talked with him, understood his difficulties, and had promised support.

To block all loopholes, I took the second step of "delivering the stick": First, I required all regions to strictly enforce company policy; anyone who made exceptions would have to make up the shortfall. I also publicly criticized Qiu's regional supervisor for being too slow. Second, I held a coordination meeting with the finance department to align with the sales department and strictly implement the new policy. Third, I agreed with the general manager to unify the message and delegate full authority to the sales department.

After that, Qiu's efforts to circumvent the policy were largely ineffective, and he reluctantly accepted rebates based on actual monthly payments. Of course, he still complained: "Director Wang, your policy is good, but it's too strict now. Business is hard; I'll have to order less in the future."

Sure enough, Qiu's orders dropped the next month. Coincidentally, we had planned to hold a sales heroes meeting and next year's development plan at the international parts exhibition. At this meeting, I planned to deliver the "carrot" for Qiu: a special contribution award for him, with a gold-plated figurine (with his portrait), and a special bonus from the general manager, equivalent to two months' rebates that had not been paid earlier.

Everything went as planned. At the annual meeting, I made special arrangements:

First, I arranged for the host to highlight Qiu's cooperation history with the company and how he actively supported the company's development during the financial crisis.

Second, I arranged for the company's 70-plus-year-old chairman to present the award and bonus.

Third, I gave him ample time to deliver his acceptance speech.

At the meeting, one sentence from Qiu's speech stuck with me: "I, old Qiu, admit that I like to take small advantages when cooperating with manufacturers, because many manufacturers like to fool me. But with Company L, I cooperate openly and honestly, because only Company L truly understands me!"

Qiu's subsequent actions proved he wasn't lying. By the end of the month of the meeting, his orders exceeded normal levels, and his total sales for the year increased significantly, with an annual payment rate of 95%—a first in Company L's history.

[Commentary] "Praising" is also a "carrot"

If you often see loyal distributors forged through "no discord, no concord," you'll also see loyalty cultivated through "praising"—whether it's young, passionate, humble newcomers or stubborn, old-timer big names, "praising" can build loyalty.

"Praising" means elevating and respecting. Knowing how to praise is wisdom; being willing to praise is generosity. For marketers, "praising stars" is a management investment and can serve as a "carrot."

Marketers who know how to praise are wise.

Their common technique is "packaging the future, attacking the heart with fame."

First, internal momentum.

The regional manager notices every improvement of Distributor A, such as increased sales today, new customers tomorrow, or a creative promotion method... During work breaks, the manager vividly recounts these stories, and after reporting, always suggests: "Boss, when can you visit? Boss A really wants to meet you."

Moreover, the manager often mentions his "star": "Good news! A recently landed a new client with a clever approach... This month's sales are secured!"

Thus, colleagues and the department manager remember that this regional manager has a "capable" distributor.

Second, bringing them to the stage.

At company distributor meetings or regional meetings, A is always asked to arrive early, speak proactively, meet leaders, and mingle with other important distributors. Soon, A's good ideas and bold moves are showcased boldly in front of the company and distributors.

Third, appropriate "praise to kill."

Behind closed doors, the manager often pressures A: "Your methods are well-received in the company; everyone admires you! I recommended you first for the outstanding distributor award. The manager will visit you in a few days... You're a company celebrity now; you need to set an example. Sales should reach a new level in the next six months!"

Under the spotlight, A works even harder, and sales keep rising. A loyal "star" distributor shines under the "star-making project."

Even the company's top leader often mentions A and privately asks about A's activities and ideas. A's practices and thoughts become the company's "model," occasionally receiving special attention and policy support.

Thus, for marketers to secure long-term distributor loyalty, they must not only build good relationships but also strive to secure a place for distributors within the company. When distributors gain attention from the company and influential managers, both you and they increase the chances of success.

--------------------------------------------