Tip: Click the blue text above to follow "FMCG Distributor Professional Consulting" for more insights on marketing and distributor internal management.

5 Strategies to Solve the "Promotion Without Sales" Problem

[Symptom] Promotion without sales: Promotions are run, but sales volume and revenue show little growth, or even decline.

Choose the Right Promotional Products In promotions, price is just one factor influencing consumer purchases; the product is fundamental. Choosing the wrong product is like focusing on the trivial instead of the essential.

  1. Prioritize products with high demand elasticity and differentiation, such as seasonal items.
  2. Differentiate from competitors in terms of product range and price band to maximize market share.
  3. Select products with sufficient inventory to avoid stockouts that hurt sales.
  4. When multiple products are on discount, ensure a sensible mix of specifications and price points to prevent internal cannibalization.

Choose the Right Stores Opt for stores with high foot traffic, strong sales, and wide catchment areas, or those near consumer groups with high purchasing power, such as stores in industrial zones, government/institutional areas, or business districts. Additionally, match products to store types. The requirements for product range and specifications differ greatly between shopping mall stores, community stores, campus stores, and tourist stores. Selling the right product in the right place is basic logic, but simple logic isn't always universally applied. For example, a beverage company once promoted 500ml drinks at a supermarket next to a large residential community during the Spring Festival. Despite deep discounts, sales were poor, while competitors offering larger sizes sold like hotcakes.

Time It Right and Have a Reason Especially during major holidays or store anniversaries, start promotions earlier than competitors to capture consumer inventory and gain a sales advantage. Also, give the promotion a legitimate reason, such as "customer appreciation," "store anniversary gratitude," or "National Day special." The reason must sound genuine and sincere to avoid the impression that the manufacturer is clearing slow-moving or defective stock. While everyone knows "only the buyer can be cheated, not the seller," consumers are often willing to "fall for it" if there's a plausible excuse, driven by the convenience. Once you have a reason, actively promote it. Before and during the promotion, maximize the reach and frequency of promotional messages. DM, POP, explosive price tags, insert cards, shelf talkers, store signage, and supermarket broadcasts are all effective media.

Combine Promotional Tactics Under the same marketing mix, different discount levels yield different marginal sales increases. See Table 1.

  1. The combined effect of "display stack + POP + special discount sign (showing original and current price)" is far greater than a simple "discount" alone.
  2. At the same discount level, "discount + personal selling" has a stronger combined effect than "discount + in-store advertising."
  3. With the same display, a 15% discount generally leads to a greater sales increase than a 10% discount, exceeding the 5% difference in discount.
  4. Always show the original and current prices during the promotion. Don't underestimate this small detail—it significantly boosts sales at the point of purchase. After showing both prices, sales typically increase by about 20%.

Pass More Benefits to Consumers, Less to Retailers Before the promotion, sales staff must consider the retailer's markup rules and ensure that the markup during the promotion is lower than the usual markup. Some retailers, after receiving substantial manufacturer discounts, may add only a small margin or even sell at cost to attract more consumers with a shocking price. However, more often, retailers increase their own profits by absorbing the manufacturer's discount, which is detrimental to stimulating end-consumer demand.

[Symptom] Promotion without profit: Sales volume or revenue increases, but after deducting all costs, profits decline—essentially working hard for nothing.

Set a Reasonable Discount Level: Too Much Is Wasteful, Too Little Is Ineffective! Consider four key factors affecting product demand elasticity:

  1. The necessity of the product. The more necessary, the higher the elasticity; conversely, the lower. Selling combs to monks versus to beauties requires different price concessions.
  2. The availability and degree of substitutes. If there are few competitors or the product is highly differentiated, the discount need not be large; otherwise, it's wasted. Substitutes include not only direct competitors but also products satisfying the same need. For example, substitutes for potato chips include other chip brands, as well as sunflower seeds and pistachios. The higher the substitutability, the greater the elasticity.
  3. The proportion of consumer income spent on the product (i.e., price). The larger the proportion (higher price), the greater the price elasticity. For a 5-yuan product, a 20% discount is 1 yuan, but its appeal is far less than a 20% discount on a 20-yuan product, which saves 4 yuan! That's why products priced at 1-2 yuan rarely get promotional discounts.
  4. The product's own competitiveness. The more competitive, the greater the elasticity. For example, freshly baked bread may need only a 5% discount to boost sales, while bread nearing its expiry date may require buy-one-get-one-free or even buy-one-get-two-free.

Beyond these four factors, you also need to determine the type of demand elasticity: elastic or inelastic. A general prerequisite for a promotional discount is that revenue after the discount exceeds revenue before. Therefore, only when e>1 is a discount feasible.

So, what is a reasonable discount level? If you only pursue revenue growth, not profit growth, the formula is: When e1=1 (i.e., sales growth ratio equals price change ratio), the corresponding price is the minimum threshold for the discount. If you pursue profit growth, the formula is: When e2=1, the corresponding price is the minimum threshold for the discount. Of course, the difficulty in these formulas lies in: Sales1 requires historical data, which necessitates a long-term, systematic database. Predicting Sales2 (expected sales) has no shortcuts—it relies on experience and data, with continuous summarization, induction, and correction. Generally, a normal discount is around 6%, while a shocking price needs to be around 20%.

When determining the discount level, also note the following five points:

  1. If multiple products are on discount at the same store during the same period, the discount levels should have a gradient, not a one-size-fits-all approach.
  2. The promotional retail price should preferably be a whole number or end in .9, such as 6.9 yuan, which is more attractive than 7.1 yuan.
  3. Consider the margins of all channel members, and calculate the manufacturer's discount based on the optimal promotional retail price.
  4. Do not view the discount in isolation. As one of the costs, the promotional discount should be evaluated together with other marketing expenses (such as display stacks, non-price promotions, DM) to assess the overall return on investment. Don't do a discount just for the sake of it; sometimes a different approach yields greater sales growth.
  5. If you can learn in advance about competitors' promotional products and discount levels at the same stores during the same period, a follow-the-leader strategy can yield better results.

Manage Inventory Reasonably In particular, reduce stockpiling just before the end of the promotion to minimize discount compensation. Currently, many hypermarkets do not settle promotional discounts based on actual sales but place orders directly at the agreed discounted price, with a "first 7, last 8" rule. As a result, stores often "over-consume" the manufacturer's promotional stock, increasing the discount compensation, while not all of it is passed on to consumers.

Invest Reasonably in Fixed Costs During the Promotion According to the e2 formula, after determining the discount level, you must calculate the fixed cost investment based on a conservative sales forecast, ensuring e2>1. The forecast should not be overly optimistic. If costs are high and cannot be reduced, consider converting fixed costs (such as display fees) into variable fees paid to the retailer to reduce risk. For example, replacing a sales-based rebate with a direct display fee is a good approach.

Leverage Shocking Prices and Public Relations to Obtain Free Display Space and Retailer Support For instance, you can offer in-store demonstrators or promotional activities during the discount period in exchange for free floor displays. Or, when the discount exceeds 15%, you can often negotiate free display support. In extreme cases, if you monopolize display space, consumers have no choice but to buy from you.

Accurately Forecast Future Costs and Establish a Supply Chain Support System This is crucial for companies with volatile raw material prices or strong seasonal purchasing. Large KA retailers typically apply for promotional discounts well in advance, sometimes up to 60 days ahead. You cannot calculate based on current costs; you must use the raw material costs for the future promotional period. This requires a historical and forward-looking procurement information forecasting system, with real-time integration between production and sales, so adjustments can be made if raw material prices or supply change.

5 Strategies to Solve the "Stop Promotion, Stop Sales" Problem

[Symptom] Stop promotion, stop sales: Once the promotion ends, sales stop growing or even decline compared to before the promotion. The promotion actually borrowed from future sales.

Focus on Brand Communication and Image Building During the promotional period, strengthen communication with consumers beyond price discounts. Don't just emphasize price cuts; communicate the brand's core value or the product's key benefits and features, so consumers feel the product is good, not just cheap. For example, when a cake company launched a new product, the salesperson's first line was: "This XX cake is on special, original price 8 yuan, now 6.9 yuan, and you get a free gift." If you were a consumer, how would you feel? Wouldn't you think the merchant is "tacky"? Therefore, product promotion should be personified. Consumers buy like choosing a spouse; if it's purely for money, with excessive emphasis on material incentives, the durability is questionable. This requires the planning, product, or communication staff to develop systematic in-store communication rules to standardize messaging.

Ensure the Product Is Sold to the Right People The worst thing is not knowing your product's features, target core group, or why consumers buy or don't buy it. If the majority of end consumers are your core target group, even if each transaction is small, as long as there's a market, the "snowball" will grow.

Keep the Promotion Period Short Considering consumer purchase cycles, the optimal promotion duration is within 15 days. The longer the promotion, the harder it is to sell the product at regular prices afterward.

Manage Inventory Reasonably to Avoid Borrowing from Future Sales It's normal to stock up during a promotion, but don't overdo it, or it will backfire. Excessive inventory makes retailers and distributors think the product doesn't sell well, making them cautious about reordering. Additionally, excess stock either gets returned to the company, incurring losses like logistics costs, or gets discounted again, damaging the brand image and turning it into a "clearance item." This is the classic "stocking paradox."

Balance Short-Term and Long-Term Interests Manufacturers should determine different promotional strategy mixes based on the product's life cycle. Promotional discounts are just one strategy. For example, products that sell well naturally should have fewer discounts to extend their life cycle. Also, based on competitive strategy, determine the product portfolio—whether profit-driven, volume-driven, or defensive—and each product's role in the portfolio will influence its promotional focus. Of course, whether during or after the promotion, ensure product quality and service. If quality issues arise, resolve them promptly and communicate openly to eliminate misunderstandings and consumer bias. Never underestimate the power of word-of-mouth.

Like this article? Feel free to share it on your Moments by clicking the top right corner.

About Us: WeChat ID: FMCG Distributor Professional Consulting Account Description: 20 years of experience in FMCG distributor operations and management, specializing in distributor internal affairs: We understand distributors better than manufacturers, and we understand internal management better than distributors. Senior marketing experts help your business grow.

Learning and exchange QQ groups:

Group 1: 344257092 (full) ** Group 2: 231512457** Click "Read the original" below to enter our micro-community for interaction and questions.